Winning the battle
IN ALL FAIRNESS
There is something strangely satisfying about hurling in winter. Such is the GAA calendar, when the National League was started in autumn, or as it is now with the concluding stages of club championships now filling this space, it’s the rawness that makes it so engaging.
For all the advances of the last decade or so in terms of fitness and skill, leading to higher scoring rates, has it actually led to a better game? The quality of scores is of the highest order but much of it comes from players shooting under little or no pressure as the ball is worked to a team-mate in space.
When it comes to winter hurling, there is a greater risk at working the ball through the lines more, leading to fumbling and unforced errors, resulting in more contests and generally leading to games being more compelling.
Last Sunday was a case in point as I was fortunte enough to take in the North Under 21 ‘A’ Hurling final between Borris-Ileigh and Kilruane MacDonaghs before quickly getting home to watch the concluding stages of the Munster Club Senior Hurling semi-final between Thurles Sarsfields and Inagh-Kilnamona.
Both matches were similar in many ways, the lead rarely stretching beyond one score either way, veering this way and that, before ultimately requiring extra time for it to be settled, thankfully before a penalty shootout was required.
Winter hurling also challenges you in different ways to when the grounds are firm and the ball is running quickly, it tests your mettle as a players knows there are going be more tackles and it is going to hurt the body more, so are you up for that?
In terms of Thurles Sarsfields, better teams from the club went to Ennis during the four-in-a-row run from 2014-2017 and came away frustrated in defeat. There was a sense from this years successful county championship run that they were better set to compete in Munster, with more steel to go along with their hurling ability, and it showed on Sunday.
It would have been a travesty if they hadn’t won as they were on the front foot for a large portion of the game but, to their credit, Inagh-Kilnamona never relented and crucially got Aidan McCarthy to come to the fore just in time to force the match into an extra twenty minutes. If he isn’t recalled to the Clare panel, Brian Lohan will lose a lot of his almost complete support he has from the Banner fans.
However, this may well be a seminal moment for this Thurles Sarsfields team becoming consistent provincial and ultimately All-Ireland contenders. Bad news for every other club in Tipp but good news overall as a rising tide tends to lift all boats.
Sars didn’t look remotely perturbed at being forced into extra time after giving up a four point lead late on. It says a lot amount the mental preparation done by manager Padraic Maher, and his backroom team, for the players to dust themselves down and do again. A legendary player, he is really coming of age as a manager. His trust of his bench was most noteworthy. In the short term, his brother Ronan getting around fifty minutes into his legs increases the possibility of starting the Munster final. With Stephen Maher on a yellow card late on and carrying a knock, he was whipped off for Seosamh Ryan for his first appearance at senior level this year. Paddy Creedon had been taken off on 52 minutes but unlike his opponents who sent substituted players back into the fray, Maher trusted his panel depth, no more epitomised by Robbie Stapleton.
Only a year or two out of the under 21 grade, Stapleton had only come on in the latter games of the county championship when the matches were in hand. On Sunday, he was coming into a match of the highest intensity that still had to be won. He got to the pitch of the game immediately, comfortably filling the boots of Kieran Rossiter who had contributed four points from play at corner forward, with Stapleton firing over three in his twenty minutes on the field, including the match-winner.
I feared it might not have counted as the positioning of one of the umpires was poor considering a score not long before also contested Thankfully, it was given and Thurles Sarsfields look forward to just a third Munster final, up against a Ballygunner side looking to win their fifth title in six years, appearing in their seventeenth provincial final in all. They go into it in the perfect situation, complete outsiders despite having a hugely talented team, but they won’t see this as a free swing.